Apple, Market Research, Henry Ford and Faster Horse

Designing products that suit market needs are crucial; understanding market needs up-front increases your chances of a successful launch. If your customers are telling you they want a faster horse. . . You aren’t asking the right questions.

You’ve probably heard it a hundred times, even though there’s no evidence that Henry Ford ever said it: “If I’d asked customers what they wanted, they would’ve said ‘a faster horse.’”

Regardless of whether he said it or not, though, the statement does capture a widespread belief: “I know better. I’m the expert. Why should I take the time or spend the money to ask those ignorant consumers about an area they know nothing about?!”

Let’s pretend that Henry Ford did say that consumers would ask for a “faster horse”. The comment clearly demonstrates a lack of understanding of the primary objective of product innovation research.

It implies that when we ask questions of prospective customers, we are hoping for them to tell us the solution to their problems. Indeed, if we ask them for that, we are very likely to get a simplistic response, like “faster horse”.

However, that is not at all what we should be asking. Customers are not expert problem solvers. Coming up with a solution is your job.

The topic about which your prospective customers have ultimate expertise is the nature of the problem to be solved. This is the area that you need to explore in depth with prospective users of your new product.

RELATED:  Apple at WWDC Enables Developer Innovation: Siri Upgrades Lead the Way

Marketing research can be extremely valuable, if it is conducted with insight and if the feedback is integrated into product planning. The early experiences of two successful CEOs with quite different attitudes about pre-launch customer feedback, Steve Jobs, and Scott Cook, illustrate this point.

Despite his brilliance, Steve Jobs’ unwillingness to listen to customers cost Apple dearly in its early days.  Apple did conduct research, but management paid little heed to findings that contradicted their beliefs.

Apple spent 4 years and $50 million developing the Lisa computer. Prior to its launch in 1983, marketing research predicted disaster, but the company dismissed the forecast and made no course-corrections. Ultimately, Apple sold relatively few Lisa computers and the product was pulled in 1986. If the firm had not had deep pockets, Lisa would have brought it down.

Scott Cook, CEO of Intuit, had an entirely different approach. His Quicken software was quite successful, and he was looking for ways to extend his product line. His next idea was to develop a small-business version of Quicken, a “small-business checkbook program.”

Scott brought marketing research into the product design process very early, and our explorations indicated that small business owners were looking for an easy-to-use ledger-type system, not an automated checkbook. The preliminary scope and direction of QuickBooks were reworked to match market desires, and the launch was among the most successful in history.

RELATED:  4 Unusual Promotional Gifts for Product Marketing Managers

Designing products that suit market needs are crucial; understanding market needs up-front increases your chances of a successful launch. Before your design is set in stone, ask probing questions that explore and explain prospective users’ behaviors, problems, workarounds, irritations, and obstacles.

And, if they tell you that they want a “faster horse,” don’t stop the conversation there — explore the reasons for that desire. It’s certainly a cheaper way to learn what people will actually buy than launching a flawed product and playing catch-up later.

JENI SALL is CEO of Genesis Research Associates. She was Manager of Marketing Research at Apple from 1981-84, and conducted product development research as a consultant to Intuit from 1987 through 1999. For over 30 years, she has conducted breakthrough research for start-up and Fortune 500 companies in the consumer packaged goods, high technology, medical products, and service industries. 

David Fradin


David Fradin has trained thousands of managers throughout the world in the successful management of products. With over 47 years of experience across major companies, 75+ products and services and 11 startups, he infuses his workshops with insights gained as an expert product leader, product manager and product marketing manager at companies like Apple and HP. He was classically trained as an HP Product Manager and was then recruited by Apple to bring the first hard disk drive on a PC to market. As a result of his leadership and management skills, Apple promoted him first to Apple /// Group Product Manager and later Business Unit Manager at the same organizational level at that time as Steve Jobs. He recently authored “Building Insanely Great Products: Some Products Fail, Many Succeed…This is their Story” Lessons from 47 years of experience including Hewlett-Packard, Apple, 75 products, and 11 startups later. Go to: Amazon Store Coming soon will be "Organizing and Managing Insanely Great Products" and "Marketing Insanely Great Products." His workshops cover the founding values, vision, product lifecycle and management employed by Apple at its start and which it subscribes to today. You can learn more about his workshops at Spice Catalyst Workshops Soon to be released by Wiley and Sons, in the Early of 2017, is a seven-volume set of university-level textbooks entitled: "Foundations in the Management of Successful Products" covering keys to product success, product market strategy, marketing, soft skills, user experience, user interface, product engineering, and product support. What students will learn in the workshops, online courses and books are cover what has made Apple the most valuable company in the world today. Go to David Fradin @ Youcanbook to schedule a time to talk.
See all the articles from this author
See all the authors


Leave a Comment





Get a Job – Ace the Interview (1)
Get a Job – Ace the Interview
It was probably difficult to land that job interview, and you don't want to screw ...
Read More
product manager, A Comprehensive Guide to Hiring Product Managers
A Comprehensive Guide to Hiring Product Managers
Why Do You Need a Product Manager? There are various different inflection points in a ...
Read More
Getting a Job as a Product Manager or Product Marketing Manager
Getting a Job as a Product Manager
A client approached me recently saying, “I’m a product manager, but I can’t seem to ...
Read More

TESTIMONIALS

Hsitang L

"I have done the marketing plan and got a great score from my working company. Thanks for your course and coaching."

Took Spice Catalyst online Marketing Fundamentals Course

Hsitang L

Student

Karthik S

"Very interesting course on the effective use of Social media in marketing. Must for all the Product Marketing managers. Simple & effective delivery of content. Thanks, Professor David."

Social Media Demystified

Karthik S

Student

Spencer J.

"Excellent Course for Marketing Strategy. It was comprehensive, easy to follow, and had the perfect balance of hands-on activities and lectures that left me with a full marketing strategy and implementation plan at the end of the course. Great course for anyone starting from scratch."

Marketing Principles Course

Spencer J.

Student

Sami A

"David’s key Product Management and presentations skills were key to my success in starting up and building Apple Pacific in the early 80s."

Product Management

Sami A

Client

Peter M

"David continues to be a valued resource for general marketing expertise, industry knowledge, and product marketing know-how. We reference his clear insights regularly."

Marketing Consulting

Peter M

Client

Manish B.

"David has been an excellent coach and mentor. Very detail oriented and practical in his approach. His ideas and frameworks are simple, practical and easy to understand and adopt, being extremely effective at the same time. The concept of ‘Do, value proposition’ is one such excellent framework which not only helps in formulating compelling value proposition for the customers but is also a source of ideas for new product innovation."

Executive MBA, Bangalore India

Manish B.

Student

Mike B, Lead Generation Consultant

"David is a very experienced and talented business professional. I have witnessed this first hand, as has demonstrated his ability across multiple disciplines, including market analysis, segmentation, customer profiling, competitive reviews, product management, marketing and sales strategy development and execution, to name but a few. In addition, he has great communication skills."

Consulting

Mike B, Lead Generation Consultant

Client

Chris B. (YouSendIt)

"I met Dave through a consulting engagement while I was at YouSendIt. It was easily the single most useful and insightful consulting engagement I’ve experienced in my career. From his analysis of our industry to the product recommendations, Dave gave us actionable information that made YouSendIt a better company."

Consulting

Chris B. (YouSendIt)

Client